Difference between revisions of "Version benchmarking"

Revision as of 15:42, 1 February 2019

Here we present a comparison between different versions for a benchmark problem run in PlanWise. We call this problem Hexagons1000, it can be downloaded from here. The problem consists of one thousand simulated treatment units. The results refer to an optimization with simple even-flow constraints. The TPG-simulation includes nine forest domains and the somewhat time-consuming breeding model is activated. For each treatment unit managed with even-aged management a nature conservation retention patch is created resulting in a total of ? units. The forest is a simulated but realistic landscape with respect to age classes, site fertilities and tree species distribution.

The comparison is intended to present to users a simple form of quality and status check and give some insigth into what can be expected. Net present value is an excellent indicator for whether there has been any model changes, since it basically depends on everything calculated by the growth-and-yield simulator.

This page was/is first published with version 2.11. We intend to run the benchmark problem for each major version released.

Version	TPG-time, 1 CPU-core (s)	TPG-time, 8 CPU-cores (s)	Total NPV	NPV/ha within managed area	Final felling volume per year, all periods (m³sk/ha,yr)	Final felling volume period 1 (m³sk/ha,yr)	Final felling area per year, all periods (m³sk/ha,yr)	Thinning volume per year, all periods (m³sk/ha,yr)	Thinning volume per year, period 1 (m³sk/ha,yr)	Thinning area per year, all periods (m³sk/ha,yr)	Total production (m³sk/ha,yr)	Comment	Release notes
2.12.3		1010 s^a	20 081 186	37 527	2 681	2 622	7.35	748	331	13.6	6.23	Increased npv: New bucking algorithm, bug fixed	Version 2.12
2.12.3^c		1010 s^a	19 915 687	37 207	2 713	2 637	7.36	718	376	13.3	6.25		Version 2.12
2.11.1^b	2483s (41m 23s)^a		19 707 063	36 824	2 680	2 610	7.34	756	326	13.8	6.24		Version 2.11
2.10	2532s (42m 12s)^a	-	19 606 195	36 624	2 711	2 652	7.40	697	403	11.5	6.20		Version 2.10
2.8.0	2360s (39m 20s)^a	-	19 652 164	36 712	2 724	2 652	7.40	713	389	11.7	6.29		Version 2.8.0
2.6.0	2370s (40m 30s)^a	-	19 634 926	36 679	2 724	2 652	7.40	713	389	11.7	6.29		Version 2.6.0

^aWindows 7, Processor Intel I7-4770, 8-core, 32GB RAM. Samsung SSD 840 EVO. SQL Server 2012 Prof.
^bWith Thinning Period Delay Max = 2 and 0 in generation 1 and 2, respectively. ^cWith understorey cleaning inactivated

@@ Line 22: / Line 22: @@
 | style="background:#f0f0f0;width:10%;;"|'''Comment'''
 | style="background:#f0f0f0;width:10%;;"|'''Release notes'''
+|-style = "vertical-align: top; text-align: center;"
+|[[Version 2.12|2.12.3]]            || ||1010 s<sup>a</sup>||20 081 186||37 527||2 681||2 622||7.35||748||331||13.6||6.23||Increased npv: New bucking algorithm, bug fixed ||[[Version 2.12]]
+|-style = "vertical-align: top; text-align: center;"
+|[[Version 2.12|2.12.3<sup>c</sup>]]|| ||1010 s<sup>a</sup>||19 915 687||37 207||2 713||2 637||7.36||718||376||13.3||6.25||||[[Version 2.12]]
+<!--
 |-style = "vertical-align: top; text-align: center;"
 |[[Version 2.12|2.12.0]]||2729s <br>(45m 29s)<sup>a</sup>|| ||19 592 678||36 614||2 694||2 622||7.35||745||331||13.6||6.24||||[[Version 2.12]]
+-->
 <!--||[[Version 2.11|2.11<sup>b</sup>]]||2654s <br>(44m 14s)<sup>a</sup>||1674<sup>a</sup>||19 704 953||36 821||2 684||2 610||7.35||754||320||13.8||6.23||[[Version 2.11]]-->
-<!--|[[Version 2.11|2.11<sup>b</sup>]]||2605s <br>(43m 25s)<sup>a</sup>||<sup>a</sup>||19 719 149||36 849||2 675||2 648||7.36||744||331||12.6||6.23||[[Version 2.11]]-->
+<!--|[[Version 2.11|2.11<sup>b</sup>]]||983s <br>(43m 25s)<sup>a</sup>||<sup>a</sup>||19 719 149||36 849||2 675||2 648||7.36||744||331||12.6||6.23||[[Version 2.11]]-->
 <!--|[[Version 2.11|2.11<sup>b</sup>]]||2287s <br>(38m 7s)<sup>a</sup>||<sup>a</sup>||19 600 016||36 623||2 705||2 688||7.44||719||859||12.9||6.22||[[Version 2.11]]-->
 |-style = "vertical-align: top; text-align: center;"
-|[[Version 2.11|2.11.1<sup>b</sup>]]||2483s <br>(41m 23s)<sup>a</sup>||<sup>a</sup>||19 707 063||36 824||2 680||2 610||7.34||756||326||13.8||6.24||||[[Version 2.11]]
+|[[Version 2.11|2.11.1<sup>b</sup>]]||2483s <br>(41m 23s)<sup>a</sup>|| ||19 707 063||36 824||2 680||2 610||7.34||756||326||13.8||6.24||||[[Version 2.11]]
 |-style = "vertical-align: top; text-align: center;"
 <!--|[[Version 2.11|2.11.0<sup>b</sup>]]||2583s <br>(43m 3s)<sup>a</sup>||1674<sup>a</sup>||19 606 876||36 636||2 689||2 688||7.38||728||859||13.0||6.23||Note larger thinning volume in period 1, see [[Version_2.11#bugg211|bug 211]] ||[[Version 2.11]]
@@ Line 43: / Line 49: @@
 <!--<sup>b</sup>With Thinning Period Delay Max = 2 and 1 in generation 1 and 2, respectively.-->
 <sup>b</sup>With Thinning Period Delay Max = 2 and 0 in generation 1 and 2, respectively.
+<sup>c</sup>With understorey cleaning inactivated

Difference between revisions of "Version benchmarking"

Revision as of 15:42, 1 February 2019

Navigation menu

Search